Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

If EU countries choose how to implement a directive, is its goal optional?

Politics category photographPolitics

A note in our policy discussion calls an EU directive “just a suggestion” because national governments work out how to implement it. I thought that confused flexibility over implementation with a choice about whether the stated goal matters at all.

The EU’s guide to types of legislation distinguishes regulations, which must be applied in their entirety, from directives, which set goals countries must achieve through their own laws. The discretion described is not simply permission to ignore the directive.

How can I correct the note without making the opposite claim that every directive works exactly like a regulation? We haven’t examined any particular measure’s scope, implementation deadline or possible legal effects. I want a useful starting distinction rather than an answer to somebody’s individual legal position.

Discussion

5 community replies

Say which part is flexible: how the required result is implemented. “National implementation” should not be shortened to “optional” when the source describes a goal that must be achieved.

Keep the actual document’s label beside the discussion. Regulation, directive and recommendation aren’t interchangeable words for something the EU would like to happen.

For a particular policy, read the measure and the relevant national implementation information before drawing conclusions about dates or obligations. The broad category alone won’t answer every practical question.

Is this distinction too technical for an introductory discussion? People may only want to know whether something is binding.

It helps answer that question without erasing how the measure operates. A short explanation can say that the goal is obligatory while national implementation matters, then leave detailed legal questions to the particular text.

Join the discussion

More in Politics