Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

I tried to collect my niece's communication tablet with the phones. How do I correct the rule?

Family category photographFamily

At lunch I asked everyone to put phones and tablets in a basket. My eight-year-old niece uses a tablet to communicate, and I reached for hers with the others. My sister took it back immediately and explained. I knew about the device but had gone into automatic hosting mode.

Later one of my children asked why their cousin was allowed a screen while everyone else wasn't. I said she needed it, then moved on because I felt embarrassed. I haven't really explained either the mistake or the rule.

[ASHA's guidance says people who use augmentative and alternative communication should always have access to their communication tools, and that screen-time concerns don't apply to screens used as part of an AAC system](https://www.asha.org/practice-portal/professional-issues/augmentative-and-alternative-communication/).

I want meals where we pay attention to each other. How do I put that intention into a better rule, apologise to my niece and answer the other children without making her demonstrate or defend how she communicates?

Discussion

5 community replies

The explanation can be short: the aim was to put distractions away, and you mistakenly treated someone's way of communicating as a distraction. Tell your niece you were wrong to reach for it. She doesn't need to reassure you or show the family how it works.

Explain fairness to your children away from their cousin if possible. Her communication remains available at the meal. They don't need a diagnosis, a demonstration or a chance to vote on whether she qualifies for an exception.

Ask your sister and niece how you can be a better conversation partner at the table. You may need to slow down or leave time for a response, but let them tell you what works rather than inventing a special family procedure around her.

Would you get rid of the basket altogether? Collecting devices can become automatic, which is what went wrong here, even if the revised rule sounds better.

That is one reasonable option. You could ask people to pause recreational use while keeping their own devices with them. If you keep any collection routine, don't assume you can take a device because it looks like the others. The communication access stays in place whichever hosting method you choose.

Join the discussion

More in Family