Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

I promised my child Grandma wouldn't die from cancer. How do I correct a reassurance I couldn't know?

Family category photographFamily

My seven-year-old asked whether Grandma could die from her cancer. I said, “No, the doctors will make her better.” Afterwards I realised I had answered my wish rather than his question.

Grandma has agreed that we should give him a simple explanation of what's happening. Her treatment team hasn't given us a guaranteed outcome. My partner says changing the answer now will frighten him, but he has already asked why Grandma needs more appointments if the problem is fixed.

Macmillan advises honest conversations with children, including acknowledging questions adults cannot yet answer.

How do I explain that I spoke too certainly, share what we actually know and still give him something reassuring about the adults looking after him? I don't want the next conversation to be a flood of medical detail he didn't ask for.

Discussion

5 community replies

Correct your words in a calm moment: you hoped the treatment would help and spoke as though you knew the result. Explain the information you actually have in language he can understand. You can be reliable now without inventing another guarantee.

Agree a simple explanation with Grandma and the adults caring for him, using accurate information from her team. Consistency should mean sharing what is known, not requiring everyone to repeat your first answer.

Ask what he is wondering about before adding details. He may be concerned about the next visit, who will collect him from school or whether he can still talk to Grandma. Answering the immediate question doesn't require explaining the entire treatment plan.

Children can return to the same question. I wouldn't treat a repeated “will she die?” as proof that the first honest conversation failed or as a reason to promise certainty again.

Give a steady answer based on what you know and leave room for another question later. Remind him which adults will keep him informed and look after his everyday needs. You don't have to produce a new medical prediction each time he needs reassurance.

Join the discussion

More in Family