Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

I offered my wedding dress as a loan. My sister wants to alter it. How do we find out whether the offer still works?

Family category photographFamily

My sister asked to wear my wedding dress, and I said she could borrow it. She has now sent ideas for shortening it and removing the sleeves. I had pictured the dress coming back much as it left.

Nothing has been altered. We hadn't discussed changes, and I don't know what the proposed work would mean for the dress afterwards. Mum says I have already had my day in it and should let my sister make it hers. My sister says she wouldn't choose those changes merely to upset me; she wants to feel comfortable wearing it.

I do want to help, and I still care about keeping the dress. How do I reopen the offer without presenting my unspoken conditions as rules she should somehow have known?

Discussion

5 community replies

Say that your yes rested on an assumption you hadn't explained. She also needs to hear what you are comfortable offering now, rather than being invited to guess which changes will disappoint you later.

If you are open to considering any alteration, ask for a clear explanation of the proposed work before agreeing to it. Don't assume a change can be reversed just because everyone would prefer that answer.

Mum's view that you've had your day doesn't settle what you want to do with the dress. Have the actual conversation with your sister, including whether she would rather decline the loan than work within its limits.

If the dress can't suit her without changes you don't want, a loan with no alterations may not be useful help. Can you acknowledge that without either of you being cast as ungrateful?

Yes. You can decide against the changes and accept that she needs another plan. Don't ask her to wear something she dislikes to prove she appreciates the offer. Discuss any other help you genuinely want and can give, without promising to replace the dress or pay costs you haven't agreed.

Join the discussion

More in Family