Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

I called my brother's divorce a fresh start, and now he feels he has to act relieved. What do I say?

Family category photographFamily

When my brother told us his divorce was final, I said, 'A fresh start at last.' I meant that I hoped things would get easier. Other relatives repeated it, and now every visit seems to begin with someone telling him how exciting his new life must be.

He told me he is relieved about some things and sad about others. I replied that we were only trying to be positive. That left him explaining why he wasn't happier about a story I'd started.

How do I make room for what he actually feels and correct the tone I've encouraged? I don't want to announce his private feelings to everyone as my next attempt to help.

Discussion

5 community replies

'We meant well' answered a different question. Tell him you can see how your phrase became an expectation, and that he doesn't owe you a cheerful account of what comes next.

He can be relieved and sad without either feeling invalidating the divorce. You don't need to decide which emotion is the accurate one before you can listen.

When another relative uses the phrase, you can stop adding to it without revealing what he told you privately. 'Let's let him describe how things are' is enough; a report of your conversation isn't needed.

Ask him whether he wants you to say anything to the family at all. He may prefer that your own conversations change rather than receiving another wave of carefully worded messages.

Follow that preference. You can take responsibility for your own comment either way. If he wants a wider correction, agree the wording with him first so that repairing your mistake doesn't create a second announcement he never chose.

Join the discussion

More in Family