Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

I called Grandma's recipe a family invention. A magazine clipping says otherwise. What do I tell my niece?

Family category photographFamily

My niece is putting together a family recipe book and asked me for the story behind Grandma's celebration cake. I told her Grandma had invented it. That is what I had always assumed, and my niece wrote it down beside a photo of her.

While looking for the recipe, I found a magazine clipping in Grandma's folder with the same ingredients and method. Grandma is still alive. When I asked, she laughed and said that was where she'd got it. She has made it for our birthdays for years and never claimed otherwise; I supplied the invention story myself.

My aunt says correcting it will take the magic out of the book. I'd rather change the story before my niece finishes, but I don't want her to feel that Grandma's cake has become less special. How do I correct my confident answer without making an accusation that Grandma doesn't deserve?

Discussion

5 community replies

The lovely part of the story is still there: Grandma chose this cake and kept making it for your birthdays. Finding out where she got the recipe adds a beginning; it doesn't erase what she did with it.

Make the correction yours. 'I said she invented it, but I hadn't actually asked her. She found it in this magazine.' That prevents a small mistake in your answer from becoming a family story about Grandma deceiving everyone.

Could your niece ask Grandma why she first chose that recipe or which birthday she remembers making it for? There may be a story she wants to tell that is more particular than the one you supplied.

Would Grandma want the clipping included? A photo of the page beside her own cake might make the book more interesting than either the recipe or the birthday photo on its own.

Ask her. The clipping could sit alongside her memories without being presented as evidence against her. Let Grandma choose what she shares, and let your niece decide how to arrange it after you have corrected the claim about who invented the cake.

Join the discussion

More in Family