Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Does ranking a civic priority first mean it matters twice as much as the second?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our association asked members to put proposed priorities in order. The draft summary describes the first-ranked item as “twice as important” as the second. We asked for positions in a list, not scores for how strongly people valued each item.

The Australian Bureau of Statistics’ guide to variables explains that ordered categories establish a ranking without necessarily establishing numerical distances between them. The numbers attached to first and second place do not supply an importance ratio.

How should we summarise the rankings and then make a decision? We could agree a points system for combining answers, but I don’t want to describe a scoring rule we choose as something members actually told us about the strength of their preferences.

Discussion

5 community replies

Report the order as an order. If the form didn’t measure strength, don’t add “twice as important” to make the result sound more decisive.

Keep individual rankings separate from the method used to combine them. A summary needs to explain how the final order was produced, not suggest that every respondent submitted that same order.

A points system can be a decision rule the association considers, but explain and agree it openly. Don’t present its weights as measurements hidden inside the original rank numbers.

We still need to choose priorities. Does this mean the rankings are too limited to be useful?

They can inform the choice. Use a clear, agreed method and describe what the rankings establish, alongside other considerations the association is weighing. Their limits are a reason to interpret them carefully, not to discard them or invent an importance ratio.

Join the discussion

More in Politics