Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Does impeachment itself remove a US president from office?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our reading group’s glossary defines “impeached” as “removed from office.” I had used the same shorthand, but another member asked why accounts of US impeachment proceedings also discuss a Senate trial.

The US Senate’s guide distinguishes the House’s power to impeach from the Senate’s power to try an impeachment. Conviction requires two-thirds of the senators present; conviction of an official in office brings removal. Impeachment by the House does not itself establish that outcome.

What wording would keep the glossary short without merging the charge and the trial’s result? We are explaining the process, rather than assessing allegations against any particular person. I also want to avoid implying that the word “impeached” tells us an ordinary criminal court has convicted somebody.

Discussion

5 community replies

Define impeachment as the House bringing formal charges in this constitutional process, then give the Senate trial its own sentence. That keeps the sequence visible without making the entry very long.

When describing a particular case, name the action that actually occurred: House impeachment, Senate acquittal or Senate conviction. “They got impeached” cannot stand in for every outcome.

A glossary should help readers interpret a report, not tell them how serious they must consider the allegations. Keep that judgment separate from the procedural label.

Would describing impeachment as a charge make it sound like an ordinary criminal prosecution?

Add that it is a constitutional process in Congress. The House and Senate roles are the useful anchors; don’t replace the misleading removal definition with a claim about a criminal court’s verdict.

Join the discussion

More in Politics