Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Do identical consultation letters deserve less consideration?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our civic association is commenting on a consultation response summary. Several people used the same template. One member wants them all removed as “not independent views”; another wants the total presented as if it settled what the whole community thinks. Some submissions also add details about individual circumstances.

The Scottish Government’s 2025 seabird consultation analysis explains its handling of standard campaign text and substantively personalised responses. It is an example of a disclosed method, not a rule for every consultation. A separate 2012 Scottish Government explanation of consultation analysis explains why voluntary responses cannot simply be treated as a population vote.

I think the summary should acknowledge both the people responding and the repeated argument, while reading any added details. How would you describe that fairly? I don’t want writing assistance to erase somebody’s contribution, or repetition to stand in for evidence about everyone else.

Discussion

5 community replies

Describe the method openly: how many submissions shared a text, what that text argued, and whether additions raised other points. Don’t let a single headline number do all three jobs.

Identical wording doesn’t tell you why each person chose to submit it. I’d avoid calling the people insincere or unthinking when all you know is that they used a common text.

Check the consultation’s own published method before saying the authority counted these incorrectly. You can recommend a clearer summary without inventing a universal weighting formula.

Isn’t separating template responses from other responses just a polite way of giving them less weight?

It depends what the summary does with the distinction. It can report participation while avoiding printing the same paragraph repeatedly, and still address the argument and any additions. Explain that purpose rather than using “template” as a reason to dismiss people.

Join the discussion

More in Politics