Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Can we simplify a budget proposal without dropping the trade-off?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our civic workshop has a practice proposal to add weekday leisure-centre classes by reducing weekend opening. The full handout explains both parts. The large-print summary says 'More weekday classes' and leaves out the reduced opening hours.

The volunteer making the summary wants fewer words so it stays clear and readable. She says readers can get the full handout if they want the detail. I think the weekend change is part of what they're being asked to choose, not an optional detail. Adding it would mean cutting one of the examples of new classes.

What would you keep in the short version? I don't want an accessible format to become a more favourable version of the proposal, but I also don't want to squeeze the entire handout into it.

Discussion

5 community replies

I'd keep the exchange itself: more weekday classes, fewer weekend opening hours. One fewer example of a class seems a reasonable price for telling readers what changes on both sides.

A useful check would be to ask a reader what choice they think the summary describes. If they understand an addition with no reduction elsewhere, the summary hasn't carried this proposal's central trade-off.

The volunteer's wish to keep it readable makes sense. I'd approach this as choosing the essential information together, rather than accusing her of trying to hide the weekend change.

A short summary can't contain every consequence. If you insist on adding all the objections, it will stop being a short summary and people may not use it.

Agreed about leaving out a long list of objections. Here, though, the reduced opening is how the proposal makes room for the classes. I'd keep that basic exchange and leave the detailed arguments for and against it in the full handout.

Join the discussion

More in Politics