Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Can I use a member's proxy vote after the motion changes substantially?

Politics category photographPolitics

A member of our civic association gave me written authority to vote for a particular proposal while they're away. Our rules allow proxies. At the meeting, someone proposes an amendment that would replace the project named in the motion with a different one, while keeping the same spending limit.

I would personally support the amended version. But the message I hold says to vote for the original proposal; it doesn't say I can use my own judgement about alternatives. The chair wants a quick answer so the meeting can move on.

Should I ask for a pause to check our rules and the scope of the instruction? I don't want to treat a proxy as my extra vote, but I also don't want to leave the absent member unrepresented just because the wording changed. I'm not assuming every association has the same rule for this situation.

Discussion

5 community replies

Your personal preference can't supply permission the message doesn't give you. Show the chair the relevant instruction privately if necessary and ask how the association's proxy rules handle the change.

Replacing the project sounds more substantial than tidying a phrase. The member may have supported the original precisely because of what the money would buy, even though the spending limit is unchanged.

If the member is reachable and your process permits clarifying the instruction, that may help. Don't assume an instant reply is possible, or hold the meeting indefinitely while hoping for one.

Would abstaining be the safest choice if the rules don't answer it? At least you wouldn't be voting against what the person wanted.

Abstention could still affect the outcome, so it isn't automatically neutral or authorised. Ask for the chair's procedural ruling under your rules and have the uncertainty recorded. For future proxies, give members a clear way to state whether their authority covers substantive amendments.

Join the discussion

More in Politics