Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Can a UK statutory instrument become law without a separate approving vote?

Politics category photographPolitics

"Find the vote, or it isn't law," my cousin said when I mentioned the made negative procedure for UK statutory instruments.

We were discussing how to check secondary legislation. I had also expected a separate approving vote for every instrument. The Parliament procedure page says instruments under this procedure don't require parliamentary approval before becoming law, and explains an objection process.

I don't want to use that as a blanket defence of any regulation. We haven't identified a particular instrument or checked its dates. I do want our explanation to distinguish an argument for more scrutiny from a claim that the absence of an approving vote automatically settles legal status.

What should we look up before saying an instrument is in effect or that the correct process wasn't followed?

Discussion

5 community replies

Under the made negative procedure, Parliament says prior approval isn't required. It also distinguishes becoming law from the date an instrument comes into force. Start with the particular instrument's stated procedure and commencement provisions rather than look for one universal kind of vote.

An objection isn't automatically an annulment. The procedure page describes a motion passed within the objection period that annuls the instrument and stops it having effect. Don't describe a complaint or a proposed motion as though that result has already occurred.

For a real case, use the instrument and its official parliamentary record. If you want to question its validity, the applicable powers, procedure, and dates need examination; a general explainer can't determine that from the absence of a vote alone.

The legal-status correction shouldn't end a political argument about whether the scrutiny was sufficient. Someone can understand the procedure and still want it changed.

Yes. State which procedure applied and what happened, then make the argument about scrutiny on its own grounds. That avoids asking the status question to carry a conclusion about whether the arrangement is democratically satisfactory.

Join the discussion

More in Politics