Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Family · Advice & Questions ·

Auntie's musical card has a loose button battery. How do I withdraw my promise to let my toddler play with it?

Family category photographFamily

I was opening a musical birthday card before giving it to my two-year-old when its battery compartment came away and a button battery fell out. I put the card and battery securely out of his reach before he saw them.

My aunt says it is a card, not a toy. I replied that I would sit with him while he looked at it, because I didn't want her thoughtful present to be rejected. Now that promise is being treated as the plan.

[The Child Accident Prevention Trust advises checking for loose battery compartments, keeping batteries out of children's reach and going straight to A&E or calling an ambulance if a child may have swallowed one](https://capt.org.uk/button-battery-safety/).

How do I thank her and clearly say he won't be handling this card, without letting my wish to avoid hurt feelings decide what we do?

Discussion

5 community replies

Correct the promise directly: you offered supervised handling before thinking it through, and you've changed that plan. Thank her for remembering his birthday without promising to demonstrate his gratitude by giving him the card.

Keep the faulty item and battery inaccessible while you decide what to do with them. Follow relevant safety and manufacturer guidance rather than improvising a repair so that the original promise can stand.

Calling it a card doesn't resolve the loose compartment you actually found. Stay with that concrete fact instead of debating whether your aunt is generally good at choosing children's presents.

Could the family still appreciate the card without the toddler holding it? She may hear putting it away as saying the whole gesture was worthless.

You can acknowledge the gesture and, if there is a suitable arrangement, keep the item securely out of reach. You can also leave it put away and display another card. Appreciation doesn't depend on restoring the loose-battery card to his play.

Join the discussion

More in Family