Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for warning a new coworker that the costume-day invitation was a prank?

AITA category photographAITA

I messaged our new coworker: "Just so you know, nobody else is planning to wear a costume tomorrow."

Some of the team had told him his first Friday was our annual fancy-dress day. They planned to dress normally, then reveal the joke when he arrived. I said I didn't like making the new person the only one who didn't know the plan. A colleague said he'd enjoy it and asked me not to spoil the welcome.

I warned him anyway. He thanked me, then came in wearing a striped shirt and a small pirate badge. He said he'd decided to join the joke on his own terms.

The colleague who arranged it says I treated the team as cruel when it was meant as an icebreaker. I said the new person should get to choose whether his introduction involved being the only one in costume.

I can't prove he would have been upset. He seemed amused by the version he chose. I also told the organizer, "Try welcoming someone without using them," which sounded like a verdict on his intentions.

AITA for giving the warning instead of trusting the team's idea of fun?

Discussion

5 community replies

The warning gave the new coworker information and a choice. His pirate badge suggests he could still enjoy some of the idea without arriving under a false impression. That isn't the same as banning humor at work.

You don't need to prove he would have been deeply upset for the choice to matter. At the same time, don't claim the worst reaction as though it was inevitable. Your own account says you don't know.

The organizer heard a broad judgment in 'using them.' You could explain the specific concern more plainly: the new person hadn't agreed to be the only one outside the shared information.

He still found a way to make an entrance. The team lost the surprise they controlled, not every possibility of a welcoming joke.

That result is worth noticing without turning him into evidence that the warning was universally necessary. He made a decision with information he appreciated. The narrator can stand by providing it while softening the accusation about the organizer's motives.

Join the discussion

More in AITA