AITA for warning a new coworker that the costume-day invitation was a prank?
AITAI messaged our new coworker: "Just so you know, nobody else is planning to wear a costume tomorrow."
Some of the team had told him his first Friday was our annual fancy-dress day. They planned to dress normally, then reveal the joke when he arrived. I said I didn't like making the new person the only one who didn't know the plan. A colleague said he'd enjoy it and asked me not to spoil the welcome.
I warned him anyway. He thanked me, then came in wearing a striped shirt and a small pirate badge. He said he'd decided to join the joke on his own terms.
The colleague who arranged it says I treated the team as cruel when it was meant as an icebreaker. I said the new person should get to choose whether his introduction involved being the only one in costume.
I can't prove he would have been upset. He seemed amused by the version he chose. I also told the organizer, "Try welcoming someone without using them," which sounded like a verdict on his intentions.
AITA for giving the warning instead of trusting the team's idea of fun?