Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to call my friend's ex a terrible person after their breakup?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend said, “Please just agree he's a terrible person.” I said I couldn't honestly say that.

He'd ended their relationship shortly before a holiday they'd planned. She was devastated and wanted to talk. I listened, then started explaining that someone could make a painful decision without being a bad person overall.

She said she wasn't asking me to write his character reference. She wanted her friend beside her while she felt rejected. I replied that being supportive shouldn't require me to condemn somebody whose whole side I hadn't heard.

That sounds fair in my head. In the room, it meant she kept describing being hurt and I kept defending a distinction she hadn't asked me to debate.

I don't want to promise to agree with every angry description after a breakup. I also don't want her to think an absent person's reputation matters to me more than the friend who called. AITA for refusing the words she wanted?

Discussion

2 community replies

You didn't have to use “terrible person.” But you also didn't need to keep arguing for his character while she was describing her pain. A refusal to condemn can be brief; the defence became its own conversation.

She told you what she needed after your explanation. At that point, try answering the hurt you can recognise rather than repeatedly stating why a global verdict would be unfair.

Join the discussion

More in AITA