Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for signing only my name on a coworker's leaving card?

AITA category photographAITA

The colleague organising the card handed it back and asked whether I could add an actual message. I'd signed my name beneath everyone else's goodbyes.

The person leaving works in another part of the organisation. We've been friendly in passing, but I don't know their work well. The other messages described their huge contribution and how much they'd be missed. I didn't want to copy sentiments I couldn't honestly claim.

I said my signature meant I wished them well. The organiser said it looked as though I couldn't be bothered to write a few kind words, not as though I was carefully protecting the truth.

I could have written an ordinary good wish about whatever comes next. Instead I explained why I couldn't give a personal tribute. AITA for keeping it to my name when I didn't have a meaningful story to add?

Discussion

5 community replies

You didn't need a personal story or a claim about their work. “Wishing you well in your next chapter” would have been a genuine good wish. The organiser wasn't necessarily asking you to invent a closer relationship.

A signature isn't an insult. But your explanation may have turned a small request for warmth into a statement that this person hadn't earned anything more from you.

You can add something kind now without treating it as surrendering your honesty. A farewell card doesn't require every signer to testify to a measurable contribution.

Keep the message within what you actually mean. Don't borrow a detailed tribute from the other entries just to make yours look equally substantial.

That is the useful middle ground: goodwill without invented familiarity. The card can mark the departure even if your part in the person's working life was small.

Join the discussion

More in AITA