Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for using my friend's self-deprecating nickname when introducing her to new people?

AITA category photographAITA

“This is our resident disaster,” I said while introducing my friend. She laughed briefly, then barely spoke to me for the rest of the evening.

She calls herself a walking disaster when she loses something or misses a detail. I've heard the joke many times and thought I was using a familiar affectionate label.

These were people she'd only just met, including someone she'd hoped to talk to about their shared line of work. Afterwards she said I'd given them a summary of her before she'd had a chance to introduce herself.

I said she used the word herself. She replied that making a joke about a particular mishap wasn't the same as being announced as the person who always gets things wrong.

I wouldn't have thought of the label without her own jokes. AITA for assuming that meant it was available for me to use too?

Discussion

5 community replies

YTA. A self-deprecating remark after a lost umbrella isn't a standing introduction. You changed the audience and made the joke into a description of who she is.

You didn't need malicious intent for it to land badly. Tell her you understand the difference she explained instead of making her defend why her own joke didn't authorise yours.

If you speak to those people again, don't retell the whole disagreement to repair it. Give her room to be known through ordinary conversation rather than another story about the introduction.

Let her choose whether she wants you to say anything further. An unsolicited public correction could put her back in the centre of the same awkward joke.

Exactly. Offer a repair, but don't decide she needs another announcement on her behalf. A private apology and retiring the nickname may be what she wants.

Join the discussion

More in AITA