Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for telling the dinner table our host's mushrooms were foraged?

AITA category photographAITA

Before my friend served the mushroom starter, I told the table she'd picked the mushrooms herself and that they hadn't been identified by an expert.

She'd mentioned the picking to me in the kitchen. It was her first time gathering mushrooms for a meal. She'd compared them with pictures in a book and was pleased she'd found something to cook for us. I asked whether someone experienced had checked them. She said no and asked me not to make everyone nervous over her new hobby.

We're in the US. I had read the National Capital Poison Center's warning not to eat wild mushrooms unless an identification expert has identified them. I said I wouldn't eat the starter. Then, when she carried it out, I told the others why. Nobody had eaten it.

She took the dish back to the kitchen. We ate the rest of dinner, but she says I could have declined my portion without making an announcement that embarrassed her in her own home. I didn't call the mushrooms poisonous; I don't know what they were.

AITA for giving the other guests the information after she'd specifically asked me not to raise it?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA. Whether those mushrooms had been reliably identified was relevant to everyone being offered them. Her wish to avoid embarrassment didn't give you a good reason to keep that uncertainty from the other guests.

Your friend may have heard your kitchen question as distrust of her effort. That feeling can be real without making the meal a reasonable test of friendship. Nobody needed to eat the starter to show they appreciated being invited.

The missing step was not finding a more persuasive way to make the guests try it. It was getting expert identification before offering wild mushrooms as food. A picture match and enthusiasm for a new hobby don't replace that step.

You were careful to report what you knew rather than announce that she'd cooked poison. Keep that distinction if you discuss it again. You can stand by speaking up without claiming you discovered a specific poisonous species.

Exactly. There is no need to win an argument about what the mushrooms actually were. You didn't know, she hadn't had expert confirmation, and people were about to be served them. That uncertainty was enough to explain why you told the table.

Join the discussion

More in AITA