Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for telling my partner my new digital piano cost less than it did?

AITA category photographAITA

My partner asked how much my digital piano cost. I said $200. It was $600.

I paid from my personal hobby savings after making my agreed contribution to our shared house fund. The purchase didn't reduce that contribution. We haven't agreed to approve each other's purchases from personal money.

He often calls instruments and music lessons expensive for “something you don't earn from.” I didn't want another conversation defending a hobby, so I gave a smaller number. Later he saw the receipt when I asked him to move the delivery box.

He's upset about the lie. I said I wouldn't have felt the need to hide it if he didn't make disparaging comments. He replied that he's allowed to think something is expensive without me inventing an answer.

I want the price to be my decision. I also know I could have said I didn't want to discuss it instead of supplying a false number. AITA for thinking his reactions are part of the problem?

Discussion

5 community replies

His comments can be part of the problem, and the false answer is still yours to own. Don't make apologizing for the lie conditional on him approving the piano.

You don't have to turn a hobby into earnings to enjoy spending your own hobby money on it. Tell him that directly. A budget conversation and a debate about whether music is worthwhile are different discussions.

Agree on what information you expect to share about personal purchases. “No approval required” doesn't automatically tell either of you whether you'll discuss prices, and an honest refusal to discuss one may need its own conversation.

I can understand wanting to avoid another belittling remark. People sometimes conceal things when they expect every ordinary choice to be judged.

That helps explain the temptation. It also gives the narrator a clearer issue to raise: the repeated comments about the hobby. A smaller invented price avoids that conversation for a moment while adding a new reason for distrust.

Join the discussion

More in AITA