Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for telling Mum I don't remember our family holiday as happy?

AITA category photographAITA

Mum showed us a holiday photograph and said, “That was such a happy week for all of us.” I said it hadn't been for me.

I was a teenager on that trip. My older cousins spent most days doing things together that I wasn't included in, and I remember feeling lonely. Mum remembers the beach meals, the jokes and finally getting everyone away at the same time.

She says I took a lovely moment and made it sound as if she'd failed to give us a good holiday. I said I wasn't denying that she enjoyed it or that she'd worked hard to organise it. I didn't want my agreement added to a memory I didn't share.

My brother says I could have let Mum tell her version without correcting it. I could, but “all of us” included me. AITA for saying so at a family lunch instead of keeping my own version to myself?

Discussion

5 community replies

You can have a different memory without proving hers false. “I remember being lonely that week” is a useful distinction from “that wasn't a happy holiday.” Your account seems closer to the first, though she heard the second.

Her organising effort and your experience aren't the same thing. Acknowledging the work doesn't require reporting that you enjoyed every day it produced.

Timing still matters. If you want her to understand the loneliness, a quiet conversation may give it more room than a correction while everyone is looking at a photograph. That doesn't mean you owed a false agreement at lunch.

Let each person own the memory they actually have. Ask her not to speak for you, while leaving her free to say it was a happy week for her.

And hold yourself to the same limit. Your lonely version doesn't have to become the family's official account either. You can both remember the same trip without making one person surrender their experience.

Join the discussion

More in AITA