Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for telling friends my partner wasn't my type when we first met?

AITA category photographAITA

Someone asked whether it had been love at first sight for us. I laughed and said, “Not for me. He wasn't my type at all.”

I meant the rest of the story to be affectionate. We became friends, I got to know him, and then I wanted to date him. But before I'd got much further, one friend joked that my partner had worn me down. He went quiet.

At home he said I could have answered no without announcing that he hadn't appealed to me. I said being loved after someone gets to know you seemed more meaningful than being chosen on first sight.

He replied that I was explaining why he should enjoy being the punchline of a story about my initial lack of interest. He knows the history; it was telling it that way in front of everyone that hurt.

I wasn't trying to imply I settled for him. I can see how the first sentence let the table supply that meaning before I reached the part I liked. AITA for telling the story honestly?

Discussion

5 community replies

The history didn't need changing. The opening did. “We were friends first” would have been just as honest without setting up a joke about him having to overcome your lack of interest.

You don't control every joke a friend makes, but you can interrupt one that gets your story wrong. Did you tell the table he hadn't worn you down, or let him sit with that version? That's a more useful question than whether the original attraction was immediate.

Your explanation at home still centres the meaning you intended. He told you what being in the story felt like at the table. You can hear that without agreeing to invent a love-at-first-sight memory.

Ask him which parts of the early-dating story he's comfortable sharing publicly. That doesn't require treating the relationship as a secret; it recognises that the anecdote belongs to both of you.

That discussion should include how you respond when friends add a joke. An affectionate ending won't necessarily undo an unchallenged line about wearing someone down. You can help shape the story while it's being told.

Join the discussion

More in AITA