Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for telling a dinner guest to get out of my kitchen when she started washing up?

AITA category photographAITA

I took the sponge out of my friend's hand and said, “Please get out of the kitchen.”

I'd already asked everyone to leave the dishes because I wanted to finish serving dessert and deal with the kitchen later. She said she couldn't sit there while I'd done all the cooking and started washing anyway.

I know she meant to help. But she was moving things around while I was still using the space, and I didn't want to keep explaining what to leave where.

She came back to the table looking embarrassed. Later she said I'd treated her like a child when she was trying not to treat me like a servant. I said I'd asked her to stop before getting sharp.

AITA for enforcing the request instead of accepting a few minutes of help?

Discussion

5 community replies

You were allowed to decline help in a kitchen you were still using. Taking the sponge and ordering her out was more humiliating than another clear “I need this space; please sit down.”

She wasn't listening either. A guest doesn't get to decide that helping is compulsory because accepting hospitality feels uncomfortable. The offer stops being helpful when the host has to work around it.

Tell her you understood the intention and regret the way you sent her away. That can coexist with asking her to take your first answer seriously next time.

If you would enjoy a different kind of help, offer a concrete job, such as taking dessert plates to the table. It gives an enthusiastic helper somewhere useful to put that energy.

The guest also has to accept that there may be no job. A replacement task can be a nice option, but you shouldn't have to manage extra work assignments before you're permitted to decline washing-up help.

Join the discussion

More in AITA