Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for shushing someone at a relaxed theatre performance?

AITA category photographAITA

I turned around and asked the person behind me to keep quiet. They said, “This is the relaxed performance.”

They'd been humming and repeating a few lines. I wasn't worried about anyone's safety; I was struggling to follow the show. I said I understood that it was relaxed, but asked again if they could be quieter.

An usher then explained that audience noise was welcome at this performance. I stopped asking. At the interval my friend showed me the booking information, which had said the same thing. She'd chosen this performance and told me the label when inviting me. I hadn't read what it meant and had assumed something more casual about dress and atmosphere.

My friend says I made someone feel unwelcome in the very performance they'd chosen to attend. I said I'd asked politely and hadn't known the arrangement at first. She pointed out that I repeated the request after the person explained it.

AITA for making what would usually have been a polite request in the wrong setting?

Discussion

5 community replies

YTA for the second request. Not understanding the label explains the first interruption. Once the person told you, you had a reason to pause and check rather than ask them to meet the audience rules you'd expected.

You don't know why that person chose the performance, and they shouldn't have had to explain anything personal to justify being there. An apology for interrupting would be more useful than defending how quietly you told them to be quiet.

It's fine to discover that this format makes it hard for you to follow a show. Use that knowledge when choosing another performance. It doesn't make sense to book the relaxed option and then ask the audience around you to recreate the format you prefer.

Yes, and choosing differently next time needn't mean asking your friend to give up the format she wanted. You may need separate bookings on some occasions. The disappointment of not sharing every outing is better addressed between you than passed to another audience member.

Join the discussion

More in AITA