Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for shredding my old diaries instead of letting my mother scan them first?

AITA category photographAITA

I found my teenage diaries while clearing the last boxes at my parents' house. I took them home and shredded them.

My mother was upset when I mentioned it. She'd hoped to scan them as part of a family-history project. She remembered that I'd written about holidays, my grandparents, and the year we moved.

Those things were in there. So were private thoughts I don't want anyone reading, including opinions I no longer hold. I didn't want a digital copy either. Mum says I could have let her pick out the family memories before destroying everything. That would still have meant her reading the diaries.

I kept photographs and some school programs from the same boxes. She says it was unfair to treat the written memories as belonging only to me when the events involved all of us.

AITA for destroying them without offering the family a chance to preserve parts?

Discussion

5 community replies

Your diaries were your account of those events, including thoughts you hadn't chosen to share. The family-history project didn't make them a shared archive.

She may be mourning the loss of stories she hoped were in there. You can acknowledge that disappointment without agreeing that she should have been allowed to inspect the private pages.

If you want to contribute, write a new account of a holiday or ask her which memories she hoped to preserve. That lets you choose what to share. It doesn't have to become a replacement diary.

I understand keeping them private, but why destroy them? Your older self might have wanted to read them again someday.

That was a choice the narrator made about their own future reading. It doesn't strengthen the mother's claim to a scan now. Regret was possible either way, including regret about keeping material they no longer wanted to carry.

Join the discussion

More in AITA