Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for shouting when my niece tried to give my dog a grape?

AITA category photographAITA

“No—don't give him that!” I called across the table. My niece pulled back her hand and began to cry.

She's six and was trying to share her fruit with my dog. My sister had just told her one grape would be fine. I got there before the dog ate it and moved the bowl away.

I explained that grapes are on the ASPCA's list of foods to avoid feeding pets. My sister says she accepts the rule now, but that I made her daughter feel she'd nearly done something terrible when she was trying to be kind.

I sat with my niece afterwards and said she wasn't in trouble, and that she could ask me about a suitable treat another time. I didn't apologise for raising my voice because I wanted her to stop immediately.

My sister says I can stand by stopping the feeding and still say sorry for frightening her. AITA for treating the shout as something that didn't need an apology?

Discussion

5 community replies

Stopping her promptly was the right choice. That doesn't prevent you saying, “I'm sorry I startled you; I needed you to stop.” An apology for the fright wouldn't tell her the grape was an acceptable treat.

Your sister also needs to acknowledge that her daughter was following the permission she'd just given. Don't let the explanation leave the child as the person who should somehow have known better than the adult beside her.

The dog didn't eat the grape, so this account doesn't require anyone to guess about symptoms or a dose. Keep the lesson simple: check with you before offering your dog food.

You've already reassured your niece that she wasn't in trouble. Adding an apology for the volume could finish that repair without reopening the disagreement about what the dog may eat.

Exactly. She doesn't need a verdict on whether your reflex was justified. She needs to know her attempt to be kind didn't make you angry with her. You can explain the urgent stop and offer that reassurance together.

Join the discussion

More in AITA