Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for saying “we're not engaged” when my partner introduced us as practically engaged?

AITA category photographAITA

At a friend's dinner, my partner introduced me as “my girlfriend, though we're practically engaged.” I said, “We're not engaged. We haven't decided that.”

The table went quiet. He laughed it off, but later said I'd made him look foolish.

We've talked about liking the idea of a small wedding someday. We haven't agreed to marry or discussed a time frame. When he says “when we're married” privately, I usually answer “if we get there.” Apparently he hears that as playful wording. I mean the distinction.

He says his introduction just meant we're serious, and I should have smiled and corrected him afterward. I didn't want people leaving with an impression I hadn't agreed to. I also didn't want to discuss our unresolved future across a dinner table, so I left the correction there.

AITA for saying it publicly? I could have sounded warmer, but I'm unsettled that he thought it was an accurate description.

Discussion

5 community replies

“We haven't decided that” corrected something you hadn't agreed to announce. His casual intention didn't make the description accurate. NTA.

His embarrassment can be real without making your correction wrong. I'd separate an apology for sounding sharp from an apology for telling the truth. You can offer the first if it fits how you spoke.

The private conversation matters more than the dinner verdict now. He hears “if we get there” as banter, while you mean uncertainty. Tell him plainly whether you're considering marriage with him and what remains undecided. If you aren't ready to answer, that itself is something he needs to understand before he introduces you this way again.

I can understand him hearing the immediate correction as “don't get your hopes up.” If you do see a future together, include that when you talk rather than only explaining the wording he shouldn't use.

Yes, if it's true. But reassurance shouldn't become a promise made to repair an awkward dinner. The unresolved part of the post is whether they mean the same thing by a serious relationship.

Join the discussion

More in AITA