Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for returning my friend's favourite novel without finishing it?

AITA category photographAITA

I gave the book back and said I'd stopped reading. My friend asked whether I'd even reached the part she'd wanted me to understand.

She'd lent me her favourite novel after telling me it meant a lot when she was younger. I said I'd read it. I got partway through and wasn't enjoying it, so I stopped rather than keep the book for months while avoiding it.

She says she wasn't asking for a review; sharing it was a way to show me something important about herself. I said I cared about her without having to like the same writing. She replied that I'd made it about taste before hearing why she'd chosen that book for me.

I hadn't asked much about that history when she first lent it. I assumed the story would explain what she wanted to share. AITA for stopping when I didn't want to finish?

Discussion

5 community replies

You can stop reading a novel you aren't enjoying. But don't claim that beginning it was exactly the same as doing what you'd promised. Acknowledge that you changed your mind about finishing.

She seems to have wanted a conversation about what the book meant to her. You could still have that conversation without pretending the novel became one you liked.

Returning it honestly was better than giving an invented reaction to an ending you hadn't reached. Keep that honesty kind: “It wasn't connecting with me” needn't become a verdict on the taste she formed when younger.

If you're curious, ask which part mattered to her and why. That is different from asking her to summarise the rest so you can claim you've effectively finished.

Right. Let her choose how much she wants to share, rather than assigning her the job of replacing the reading you declined. You can own the unfinished promise and still offer a different kind of attention.

Join the discussion

More in AITA