Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for returning my ex's letter unopened instead of reading it for closure?

AITA category photographAITA

I returned the sealed letter with the last of my ex's books. He says reading it would have cost me very little after the time he spent writing it.

We broke up several months ago. I'd asked that our remaining contact be about returning belongings. He put the letter in a box of things he brought back to me and messaged that it explained his regrets and said goodbye.

I don't want another account of the breakup to work through. I didn't open it, and when I returned his books I included it with a note saying I wasn't ready to receive a personal letter.

He says he wasn't asking for a reply or trying to restart the relationship. A mutual friend thinks quietly reading it would have been kinder than making him know I refused.

I wasn't trying to punish him. I wanted to make clear that I wasn't taking on this last conversation, even on paper. AITA for returning it rather than reading without responding?

Discussion

5 community replies

Writing it was something he chose to do. You had already asked to keep contact practical. The effort doesn't automatically make reading it a task you agreed to take on.

Returning it made the refusal visible, which may be the part that hurt. You can recognize that without agreeing it would have been better to pretend you'd read it.

If you don't want further letters, say that directly rather than “not ready” if that phrase leaves a possibility you don't mean to offer. Be accurate about what you want now without promising a future conversation.

Reading privately without replying can be different from agreeing to talk again. I can see why the mutual friend thought it was a small kindness.

It can be that for someone who wants to read it. The narrator says they don't want another account to work through. Not replying would limit the outward conversation, but it wouldn't remove the experience of reading something they had declined.

Join the discussion

More in AITA