Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for repeating my partner's words back to prove I was listening?

AITA category photographAITA

“You haven't heard a word,” my partner said. I put my phone down and repeated the last few sentences she'd said. Accurately.

She'd been talking about an awkward exchange with her sister. I was ordering a replacement light bulb and thought I could do both. When I repeated her words, I meant to show I hadn't ignored her. She said it felt like being cross-examined.

I asked what information I'd missed. She said that wasn't the point: she'd wanted a conversation, and I'd barely looked up or responded. I said she could have asked for my full attention instead of claiming I hadn't heard anything.

We ended up arguing about the accusation rather than her sister. I did remember what she'd said, but I hadn't really thought about what I wanted to say back. AITA for correcting her when the specific thing she accused me of wasn't true?

Discussion

5 community replies

You won a very narrow factual argument and lost the conversation you were having. Repeating the words didn't answer her wish for your attention.

She could have said “please put the phone away” instead of “you haven't heard anything.” Still, once she explained what bothered her, insisting on the wording kept you from responding to the clearer request.

“I heard what happened, but I wasn't giving you much back. Let me finish this order, then can we start again?” That would acknowledge the distinction you're making without requiring her to defend the accusation first.

I don't think anyone should have to drop every task whenever their partner begins talking. Sometimes people really are in the middle of something.

That's a good reason to say, “I'm ordering something. Can we talk in five minutes?” The narrator could have finished the task and then offered a conversation, instead of trying to prove that remembering the words was enough.

Join the discussion

More in AITA