Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for rejecting a compliment that compared me with my partner's ex?

AITA category photographAITA

My partner's sister said, “The best thing about you is that you're nothing like his ex.” I replied, “I'd rather you tell me something you like about me.”

We were having dinner with his family. His sister says the ex treated him badly and meant that she was relieved to see him happy. I don't know the ex, and I wasn't trying to defend her conduct. I just disliked being welcomed through a comparison with somebody who wasn't there.

My partner says I made his sister feel accused when she was trying to be warm. I said she could call me kind, funny or good company without needing an example of a worse girlfriend. He replied that I could also have accepted the intention instead of requesting a replacement compliment.

I haven't asked his family never to mention the past. AITA for pushing back at the table?

Discussion

5 community replies

“I'd rather you tell me something you like about me” is pointed, but the underlying request makes sense. You want them to know you as a person, rather than treat you as evidence that the previous relationship was worse.

His sister may hear that sentence as “try again, that compliment wasn't good enough.” If you like her and want a warmer relationship, tell her you understood the welcome. Then explain why comparisons with the ex make you uncomfortable.

You don't need to investigate the ex's behaviour to earn this preference. Whether she was wonderful or dreadful doesn't determine how you want his family to talk about you.

Your partner may have heard your objection as dismissing his family's relief that he's happy. You can acknowledge that relief while saying you'd enjoy getting to know his sister without being measured against the previous relationship.

And he can help with that introduction instead of asking you to keep accepting the comparison. His sister's warm intention and your discomfort can both be real. Neither requires you to offer a verdict on a woman you've never met.

Join the discussion

More in AITA