Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to sign my friend's petition after agreeing with the idea?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend handed me a petition about adding benches to our building's shared garden. I started reading it. She said, “You've already told me you support this. Can you just sign?”

I do want more benches. But the text also called for removing the vegetable beds to make room for them. I hadn't agreed to that, and a neighbor puts a lot of work into those beds. I said I'd support exploring more seating, not this exact proposal.

My friend says I was splitting hairs after she'd spent a weekend organizing something people had asked for. The layout wasn't final, she said; signatures would only show there was interest. I asked why the petition didn't say that instead of asking for the beds to go. She took the paper back.

Later she said reading it so critically in front of another neighbor made it look as though she was trying to slip something past us. I wasn't accusing her of that. I wanted to understand what my name would be attached to.

AITA for refusing after she'd reasonably expected my support?

Discussion

5 community replies

Agreeing with more seating isn't the same as agreeing to remove the vegetable beds. Reading the proposal before adding your name was reasonable.

You could thank her for the organizing without signing. Those aren't competing positions. Her work matters, and the actual wording still matters.

Offer a sentence you'd be willing to support if you want to stay involved: “We'd like the building to explore additional seating while consulting people who use the garden.” She can decide whether that fits her aim.

I can understand her feeling ambushed by a detailed challenge in front of someone else. Could you have taken it away to read rather than questioning her there?

Perhaps, but she was asking for a signature there and then. A normal question about a visible part of the proposal shouldn't need a private meeting. Tone could be worth discussing without making scrutiny itself an insult.

Join the discussion

More in AITA