Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to share my interview exercise after my friend shared hers with me?

AITA category photographAITA

"I told you everything they asked me," my friend said. "Now it's your turn."

We are applying for similar jobs at different companies and agreed to help each other prepare. After her interview, she described several questions and the task she'd been given. I listened, took notes and thanked her.

At my interview, I was specifically asked not to pass the exercise on to other applicants. When my friend asked how it went, I described the general topics and how I felt I'd done, but wouldn't give her the exercise or exact prompts.

She says our agreement was mutual and that I accepted help before finding a reason to hold mine back. I told her I hadn't known about the request beforehand. She replied that I could have said I didn't want detailed information from her if I wasn't sure I would reciprocate.

I don't want to ignore what the interviewer asked. I also felt relieved to have a clear reason not to share material from a role I really wanted. That extra motive makes me less comfortable presenting this as entirely about principle.

AITA for limiting what I shared after taking the fuller account from her?

Discussion

5 community replies

The specific request not to pass on the exercise is new information you didn't have when agreeing to prepare together. You can acknowledge the imbalance without deciding that accepting her help requires ignoring it.

Your relief about keeping an advantage is worth admitting to yourself. It doesn't automatically make the boundary false. People can have mixed motives and still need to respect a request they were explicitly given.

Offer the help you can actually give: practice general questions, talk through her approach or discuss broad topics from your experience. Be clear that this isn't equivalent to the exact material she shared, rather than overselling it as a complete repayment.

Did 'help each other prepare' originally mean sharing every detail afterward, or did that expectation form when she volunteered hers? You may remember the agreement differently.

That would be worth clarifying before the next application. It won't erase her disappointment this time, but it can stop another implicit exchange building around information one person later isn't willing or able to share.

Join the discussion

More in AITA