Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to remove my friend's ex from our group chat?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend asked me to remove her ex from our group chat. I said I wouldn't do it just because they'd broken up.

The chat is for a group of us who plan quizzes and days out. He was part of it before they dated, and several of us are friends with him independently. I happen to be the admin because I started the chat.

She says seeing his ordinary messages makes it harder to move on. She hasn't described him using the chat to target her; she wants one social space where she doesn't have to see him.

I said I could organise separate plans with her, but didn't want to use an admin role to decide which of two existing friends kept the group. She says offering smaller plans leaves her excluded from the main conversation.

I offered to hand the admin job to someone else. She said that was avoiding the choice rather than supporting her. I can see that passing the role on doesn't solve her discomfort. AITA for refusing the removal anyway?

Discussion

5 community replies

Being the admin doesn't make you the sole owner of everyone's friendships. It's reasonable not to treat access to the group as something awarded to whichever person asks you first after a breakup.

She is describing a real loss: a familiar space no longer feels comfortable. Your refusal will be easier to hear if you acknowledge that cost instead of talking only about the limits of the admin job.

Separate invitations can be meaningful support, but they aren't identical to keeping the original group unchanged for her. Don't offer them as though they remove every consequence of your decision.

A group conversation about future plans may help, but avoid turning it into a public vote on which former partner people want to keep. That could make both of them feel as if their friendships are being counted.

Exactly. The question can be how to handle invitations and shared activities, rather than staging a popularity contest to bless an expulsion. You can keep your own decision while making room for her to attend less often.

Join the discussion

More in AITA