Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to recreate my reaction to my sister's birthday gift?

AITA category photographAITA

“Open it again, but wait until I've started recording,” my sister said. I put the lid back on the box and told her I didn't want to do a second take.

She'd made me an album of messages and photographs from people I care about. I was delighted. I'd already hugged her and started reading when she realised her phone hadn't recorded the opening.

She wanted me to close it, act surprised again and repeat what I'd said. I said the first reaction had been for her, and I wasn't going to perform another one for the camera.

That sounded more pointed than I meant it. She says she spent weeks making the album and wanted a record of giving it to me, not a performance for strangers. I know she wasn't planning to post it. I still didn't want to fake discovering the gift.

AITA for declining instead of doing one short retake?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA for refusing to act surprised twice. The gift was received with joy; the recording failed. Those aren't the same event, and you don't have to recreate the first to repair the second.

“The first reaction was for you” may have sounded like an accusation that she cared more about a clip. You can clarify that you know she wanted a keepsake and still say recreating the surprise felt uncomfortable.

If you want a recording together, film yourselves looking through a page and talking about it now. That could be an honest memory of enjoying the album, rather than a substitute discovery.

Don't turn this into a test of whether her gift was truly generous. Wanting a private video doesn't erase the work she put into the album. The specific thing you declined was acting out the opening again.

Exactly. You can thank her warmly and keep that limit. She can be disappointed about missing the clip without either of you having to prove the other cared about the wrong part.

Join the discussion

More in AITA