Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to read an apology that says I was jealous?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend sent me the apology she wants me to read to our dinner group. Most of it describes what I actually did. One sentence says, “I tried to spoil your good news because I was jealous of you.”

At dinner she was showing us pictures of her new flat. I interrupted with, “Do we get another tour with every course?” People laughed, and she stopped showing the pictures. It was a mean thing to say. I apologised to her afterwards and offered to tell the group I had been rude, so she wouldn't have to pretend the joke was fine.

She says an apology that leaves out jealousy avoids the real problem. I was irritated that the conversation had stayed on the flat for so long. That doesn't make my interruption fair, but I don't recognise the motive she's asking me to announce. I said I would own the comment and the embarrassment I caused, but couldn't honestly read that sentence.

Now she thinks I'm negotiating the wording so I can keep believing I'm the good person. I'm willing to apologise in front of the people who heard me. AITA for refusing her explanation of why I did it?

Discussion

5 community replies

You owe her a clear correction in front of the people who laughed. You can say you turned her happy news into a joke at her expense without announcing a motive you don't believe was there. Don't let the disputed sentence become a reason the public apology never happens.

Your explanation still deserves a closer look. What made her taking up the conversation feel like something you needed to punish with a joke? That doesn't prove jealousy, but “I was irritated” is the beginning of examining your reaction, not necessarily the end.

The group laughed at a comment that shut her down. A useful apology could make that moment less comfortable for you: “You were sharing something exciting, and I made you feel foolish for enjoying it.” You don't need to add a speech about how long the photos took.

Tell her which sentence you can't say and offer your actual wording. Rejecting the whole script with “you can't tell me my motives” could sound as though you're rejecting her account of being hurt as well.

Agreed about offering wording, but she doesn't have to approve every word before you can take responsibility. Keep her hurt in the apology; leave the argument about jealousy out of the dinner-group conversation. She can still decide that your apology hasn't repaired the friendship.

Join the discussion

More in AITA