Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to rate my friend's appearance out of ten?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend showed me a new photograph and asked for an honest score out of ten. I said I didn't want to give one.

She said refusing was worse than a low number because it meant I couldn't think of anything nice. I told her I liked the haircut and the colour she'd chosen, but didn't want to turn her appearance into a mark.

What complicates this is that I've joined in when friends rated photographs of celebrities. She says I can't suddenly act as though numbers are beneath me when it's her asking.

I don't feel good about that earlier game either. But I also don't want to supply a score she'll have to interpret as a statement about how I see her. AITA for declining the exact answer she asked for?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA for refusing the score. You can answer a question about the photograph without accepting the numerical format. The specific compliments you gave were an answer, even if not the one she wanted.

She has a fair point about your inconsistency. Own the earlier rating game rather than defending it as harmless just because the subjects weren't in the room.

Her reading of the refusal as a concealed low score isn't something you can fix by finding the perfect number. Explain that you don't want her appearance reduced to a rating from you.

If you offer a compliment, make it something you actually think. Don't pour on exaggerated reassurance to compensate for the missing number.

Yes. A believable observation about the haircut is more honest than an inflated score offered to make the conversation end. You don't need to turn the refusal into a second performance of judgment.

Join the discussion

More in AITA