Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to plug a USB drive my friend found into my laptop?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend found a USB drive under a chair at a community event. She wanted to plug it into my laptop to look for the owner's name. I said no.

I had the laptop with me because I'd been working before we met. She said a quick look might reunite someone with important files, and I could simply avoid opening anything that looked suspicious. I wasn't comfortable treating that as a safe plan.

I suggested giving the drive to the event office with a note about where she'd found it. She said that was passing the problem to someone who might put it in a drawer. I replied that I wasn't volunteering my laptop as lost property's inspection desk.

The Australian government's device-security guidance recommends using external devices only from trusted sources and notes that unknown removable media can contain malware. We didn't connect the drive.

My friend says the refusal was mine to make, but the inspection-desk remark made her effort to help sound foolish. AITA for shutting the suggestion down that way?

Discussion

5 community replies

The refusal was reasonable. You didn't know the drive's source, and the linked guidance supports being cautious about unknown removable media. Returning it through the event office was still an attempt to help.

Your friend's intention wasn't foolish. She was trying to identify the owner. You can say that while standing by a decision not to use your computer for the search.

I'd apologize for the inspection-desk line if it sounded contemptuous. “I want it returned too; I don't want to connect it to my laptop” would have kept the disagreement on the proposed action.

She may have heard every alternative as a reason to do less. It could help to offer to walk the drive over to the event office with her.

That's a useful offer if the narrator wants to make it. It shows the refusal is about connecting the device, rather than indifference to the owner. It shouldn't become a requirement to prove they were allowed to say no.

Join the discussion

More in AITA