Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to mediate a camera dispute after seeing my friend take it without permission?

AITA category photographAITA

Our friends asked me to sit down with Ben and his flatmate and help them “both apologise and move on.” I said I wouldn't chair that conversation unless Ben first admitted taking the camera after being told no.

I was there when he asked to borrow it for an afternoon. His flatmate said no because she needed it later and didn't want anyone taking it out. When she left the room, he took it anyway. He brought it back that evening. I'm not aware of any damage.

Ben says he returned it and that her angry messages were out of proportion. She says the point is that he'd asked, heard the answer and ignored it. I agree with her on that.

The others think I'm the obvious person to help because I witnessed the exchange. They say a calm conversation could get them talking again. Ben says my condition proves I'd already decided who was wrong, so I couldn't listen fairly.

I can describe what I saw. I don't want to host an exercise where equal apologies are the expected ending. But by setting a condition instead of simply declining, have I tried to dictate the outcome myself?

Discussion

5 community replies

You aren't neutral about the taking because you witnessed the refusal. That's a sound reason to offer a factual account and decline the mediator role. They need to stop treating a witness and a referee as interchangeable.

Your condition does prescribe an opening concession. If you don't want the role, say no. “I'll mediate once he admits I'm right about the first issue” isn't likely to produce the calm conversation the group says it wants.

The absence of damage answers a different question from whether she gave permission. A useful discussion could address both the taking and whatever was said afterwards, without deciding beforehand that the apologies must be equal.

Were Ben and his flatmate both asking for this conversation, or was the rest of the group trying to arrange it? If one of them doesn't want a meeting, selecting a neutral chair is getting ahead of the actual problem.

Even if they both want to talk, that doesn't oblige you to chair it. You could give them the same short account of what you witnessed and let someone else handle the conversation. Neither of them should have to guess whether you're speaking as a witness or deciding the settlement.

Join the discussion

More in AITA