Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to make my daughter say she enjoyed a meal she disliked?

AITA category photographAITA

My aunt asked my nine-year-old whether she'd enjoyed the vegetable bake. My daughter said, “Not really, but thank you for making dinner.”

I said nothing. Later my aunt told me I should have prompted her to say it was lovely, because she'd spent the afternoon cooking for us.

My daughter hadn't complained during the meal or made faces. She ate the parts she liked and thanked my aunt when we left. I don't want her to think courtesy requires giving a false opinion when someone asks directly.

My aunt says “not really” was unnecessarily blunt, and I could at least have helped my daughter find something kind to say about the dish. I replied that she'd already said thank you. That ended the conversation rather abruptly.

AITA for thinking gratitude was enough without also praising the food?

Discussion

5 community replies

Thanking the cook was appropriate. I wouldn't ask her to declare the meal lovely if she didn't think so. You can still teach a gentler response without calling the one she gave a moral failure.

Your aunt probably wanted to hear that her effort had landed well. Acknowledge the afternoon she spent cooking yourself, instead of making a nine-year-old responsible for repairing that disappointment.

If your daughter liked one part, she could mention it next time. That's an option for honest kindness, not a requirement to search for praise under pressure.

I agree she shouldn't lie, but “not really” can sting. The parent could have added something warm rather than staying silent and leaving the child to carry the whole exchange.

That's a fair distinction. The narrator could thank the aunt for hosting or name something they enjoyed themselves. Supporting the daughter's honesty doesn't require everyone else to become silent too.

Join the discussion

More in AITA