Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to lend my work laptop when I use it for my own shopping?

AITA category photographAITA

My sister pointed to the shoes I'd just ordered and said, “So personal use is fine when it's yours?”

Her laptop had stopped working, and she wanted mine for a job application due that evening. The laptop I had with me belongs to my employer. Our written rules permit incidental personal use by the employee, but don't permit another person to use the work account.

I showed her that distinction. She said I could open a private browser window and sit beside her, so nothing would be saved and nobody would know.

I said no. I offered to help her look for another device, but couldn't promise we'd find one before the deadline. She says I chose a rule over a job opportunity when I'd already shown I wasn't strict about keeping work and shopping separate.

I do understand the urgency. I don't think it makes my permitted use and lending her the account the same choice. AITA for refusing?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA. In the rules you've described, your shopping and another person using the account are treated differently. She can dislike that restriction without making it disappear by pointing to your shoes.

A private window isn't a promise of invisibility. Mozilla's guidance says some private-window activity may still be visible to an employer on a work computer or network. That doesn't establish what your particular employer records, but it undercuts the assurance that nobody could know.

Her deadline explains why she was pressing. It doesn't mean you owe her access to a device you're responsible for under rules she hasn't agreed to follow.

Keep any alternative offer realistic. Help her contact someone with a personal device if you're willing, rather than saying “we'll find something” when you don't know that you can.

Yes. An honest offer of effort is still help even if it doesn't guarantee a submitted application. Don't turn the refusal into a promise you may have to break later that evening.

Join the discussion

More in AITA