Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to lend my cousin my prescription skin cream?

AITA category photographAITA

My cousin showed me a photo of the prescription tube she uses at home. It looked like mine. She'd forgotten to pack hers for a family weekend and asked to use some of mine.

I said I wasn't comfortable sharing a prescription. She said she wasn't asking me to choose a treatment; she already had the same thing prescribed and just needed enough until she got home. She offered to use a clean spoon so she wouldn't touch the opening.

I repeated no. When she asked again while we were setting out dinner, I said, “I'm not the family pharmacy.” Two relatives heard. She stopped asking, but later told me I'd made her sound like someone begging for pills rather than asking a practical favor.

I wasn't trying to make a judgment about her hygiene or whether she was telling the truth. I just didn't want to lend medication. I also didn't want to spend dinner comparing labels and deciding whether that changed my answer.

She says I could have refused without making a performance of it. I think she could have accepted the first refusal. AITA for how I handled this?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA for refusing. You don't have to inspect her photo and then negotiate an amount. She asked for something you weren't willing to share, and the repeated requests are part of why the exchange became tense.

The FDA's medication guidance says not to share prescription medicines. For the practical question of what to do without her own tube, her pharmacist or prescriber is a better person to ask than a cousin at the dinner table.

The clean spoon answered a hygiene concern you hadn't raised. Clarify that you were declining to share medication, not calling her dirty.

“Family pharmacy” was a jab. You can apologize for making the refusal pointed in front of other people without offering the cream or accepting another round of label comparisons.

Yes. An apology for the jab would be more convincing if it stands on its own. Then, separately, ask her not to keep reopening a medication request after you've answered it.

Join the discussion

More in AITA