Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to keep editing my cousin's CV after she restored a claim I removed?

AITA category photographAITA

I changed “managed a team of five” to “coordinated meeting times for a five-person project.” My cousin changed it back.

She'd asked me to help with her CV. When I asked what managing the team involved, she said she'd booked the rooms and reminded classmates of deadlines. Nobody reported to her, and she hadn't assigned or reviewed their work. I thought the first wording gave a different impression.

She says all CVs make ordinary work sound stronger, and mine made her sound like the person who sent calendar invitations. I offered to help describe what she actually contributed in more detail. She said I was getting stuck on one phrase instead of helping her compete.

I then told her I didn't want to keep editing it. She says she asked for writing help, not permission to choose how she presents herself, and that abandoning the whole task was dramatic.

AITA for stopping over a claim she understands differently from me?

Discussion

5 community replies

You can decline to help write a description you don't believe is accurate. She can still choose her own wording; that doesn't require you to keep contributing.

I'd avoid making this “all CVs are honest” versus “all CVs exaggerate.” Ask what a reader would reasonably understand by managed, compared with the work she described. That's the actual disagreement.

There may be strong material in the project: keeping a schedule, following up, solving a coordination problem. Invite her to explain those contributions before writing a more impressive label for them.

Coordinating peers can involve leadership even without formal reports. Removing every strong word could undersell her.

Agreed about leadership. She could describe taking initiative or keeping the project organized if that's what she did. The concern is the specific claim to have managed a team, not a rule that student work must sound unimportant.

Join the discussion

More in AITA