Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to give every question the lowest score on our workplace survey?

AITA category photographAITA

My coworkers agreed to give our new rota the lowest score on every question in a staff survey. I said I'd answer honestly rather than coordinate my ratings.

I dislike some parts of the rota too. But I prefer the more predictable start times, and one survey question was specifically about that. I intended to rate it positively while criticizing the shorter notice for changes.

One coworker said mixed answers would let management claim the rota was working. She wanted a clear signal that the team wanted the old system back. I said giving a low score to something I actually liked would blur what I wanted changed.

The survey was described as anonymous, but we were discussing our planned responses openly. I didn't share anyone's answers with our manager or argue that the others shouldn't give low ratings. I just wouldn't promise to match them.

Now she says I want the benefit of their push for changes without backing the people doing the pushing. AITA for keeping my answers separate when I broadly agree there's a problem?

Discussion

5 community replies

Answer the questions as you understand them. Supporting improvements doesn't require pretending every part of the current arrangement is equally bad.

Your coworker is thinking about a clear collective message; you're thinking about accurate feedback on separate questions. Naming that difference may make this less personal, even if neither changes their plan.

You could offer to help write a shared explanation of the changes you do support. That would be a concrete contribution without promising survey ratings you don't believe.

I can see why she worries that a positive answer will be taken as approval of the whole rota. Are there comment boxes where you can explain the distinction?

If there are, use them. But neither person knows from this account how management will interpret the ratings. It's reasonable to state the concern without treating the feared interpretation as a reason everyone must give the same answer.

Join the discussion

More in AITA