Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to drive until my father put his seat belt on?

AITA category photographAITA

We were still parked outside my parents' house when I asked Dad to buckle up. He said the restaurant was only a few minutes away and told me to get going.

I said the car wasn't moving until everyone was belted. My brother had already put his on. Dad laughed and said I wasn't in charge of him. I replied, “I'm driving. This part isn't a debate.”

He eventually fastened it, and we left. There wasn't an emergency or a problem with the belt; he said he simply didn't bother on short trips. I follow NHTSA's guidance to buckle up on every trip, rather than making an exception based on distance.

At dinner he said I'd spoken to him like a child in front of my brother. I said I wasn't willing to drive him unbelted, and he replied that a request could have stayed a request.

AITA for making it a condition of the lift instead of respecting his choice as an adult?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA. You waited while safely parked and made a clear condition before driving. He could dislike the wording without expecting you to begin the trip unbelted.

The linked guidance doesn't make an exception for a short drive. Keep the explanation there, rather than making this an argument about whether a grown child is allowed to tell a parent anything.

If you want to smooth over the tone, say you weren't trying to embarrass him and that the condition will apply on future lifts too. An apology for sounding abrupt needn't become a promise to drop it next time.

He may feel that his own decision about risk should be respected, especially when he's the passenger rather than the driver.

He can make choices about which lift to accept. That doesn't require the narrator to provide one under conditions they won't accept. The seat-belt recommendation supports keeping this limit even when the passenger is an adult parent.

Join the discussion

More in AITA