Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to drive everyone home just because I wasn't drinking?

AITA category photographAITA

"Great, you're our driver," my friend said when I ordered a soft drink.

I told him I was driving myself home, but hadn't agreed to be the group's lift. There were four of us at a restaurant. I'd planned to leave after the meal and spend the rest of the evening quietly at home.

My friend said he thought I'd be happy to help since I had the car and wasn't drinking. One person lived close to my route; the other two would add a substantial detour. I offered the nearby person a lift and said the others needed another plan.

He said choosing one passenger in front of everyone made the offer look personal. I explained the route. He replied that a group outing should involve looking after the group, not calculating each person's extra minutes.

I have accepted lifts from him before, and I would usually have said yes if asked in advance. What annoyed me was being announced as the answer before anyone asked.

The others arranged a different lift. My friend says I spoiled a generous mood to defend time I wasn't doing anything special with. AITA for keeping that time?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ordering a soft drink didn't establish a transport agreement. You were clear about what you could offer before the group left, and the others found another lift. That is a different situation from withdrawing a ride they'd already accepted.

The route explanation makes the one-passenger offer understandable. Still, saying it quickly at the table could have sounded like ranking people until you explained. You can acknowledge that awkwardness without taking on the whole detour.

Your previous lifts from this friend matter to the relationship, but they don't automatically answer every new request. Think about whether you are willing to help reciprocally in general, not whether this announcement must become a debt you pay that evening.

'Nothing special' is a description of your plans, not proof the time was available for somebody else to assign. A quiet evening can be a plan you value.

That point works best without pretending friends never inconvenience each other. The narrator can value generosity and still want to be asked. An advance request would have allowed a real yes rather than turning refusal into a public dispute.

Join the discussion

More in AITA