Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing equal peer-assessment scores for our course group?

AITA category photographAITA

Before we submitted our project, one group member asked us all to give each other the same peer-assessment scores. I said mine wouldn't be equal.

There were four of us. She was dealing with a family problem and missed most of the work sessions. We knew what was happening, divided her planned tasks between us, and finished on time. She proofread the final document. I don't think she invented the problem or stayed away because she couldn't be bothered.

The assessment form asks us to describe and rate each person's contribution. It has room for comments. I told her I would describe the proofreading and the tasks we'd taken over, without giving details about her family.

She says she thought agreeing to cover the work meant we wouldn't let her be penalised afterwards. We never discussed scores until now. Another member thinks equal ratings are a small kindness now that the project is done.

I don't know exactly how our tutor will use the ratings. I also don't want mine to imply she did the same amount as the people who finished the missing sections. AITA for distinguishing between helping her through the project and giving her the same assessment?

Discussion

5 community replies

Covering her work and reporting that you covered it can both be fair. You helped the group finish; you didn't agree to describe everyone's contribution as identical. Keep your account factual rather than using the rating to express resentment.

She seems to have understood the offer as protection from the consequences of missing work, while you understood it as making sure the project got done. Neither understanding was discussed at the time. That doesn't require equal scores now, but it explains why this may feel like the terms changed for her.

The form's wording matters more than a general rule about who worked hardest. Answer what it actually asks. If it distinguishes quality, reliability and volume of work, don't flatten those into one verdict about her as a classmate.

Her family circumstances are hers to discuss with the tutor. You can encourage that conversation without putting private details into your own comments or pretending you know what adjustment the tutor should make.

Yes, and keep your report about the project, not about whether her reason was good enough. She can explain why she was absent. You can explain which tasks you did. Those accounts don't have to contradict each other.

Join the discussion

More in AITA