Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing an anniversary dinner on the date my partner and I got back together?

AITA category photographAITA

My partner booked a dinner for the anniversary of us getting back together. I said I didn't want to mark that date as our anniversary.

We first dated five years ago, split up for eight months, and have now been back together for two years. I prefer our original first-date anniversary. To me, it's the beginning of our whole story, including the difficult part. He prefers the reunion date because it marks the relationship we deliberately chose to rebuild.

We hadn't agreed on a date this year. He thought booking dinner would be a kind way to celebrate his choice. I heard it as deciding that the years before the break no longer counted.

I called it “not our real anniversary” and declined the reservation. He said he wasn't asking me to erase anything, just to celebrate a decision that matters to him. I could have enjoyed the evening without settling which date goes on a calendar, but I worried that going would establish an agreement I hadn't made.

AITA for turning down the dinner rather than making room for both meanings?

Discussion

5 community replies

You can prefer the original date without calling his date unreal. Both refer to actual parts of the relationship. That word seems to have turned a difference in meaning into a dismissal.

He also booked before you agreed. A nice reservation doesn't settle a shared ritual by itself. You can appreciate the gesture while asking to make the decision together.

What would each date celebrate for you? Talk about that before arguing which one gets the title. You might choose one, acknowledge both differently, or find another arrangement you both enjoy.

I understand worrying that attending would be treated as agreement. Sometimes a supposedly casual gesture becomes the precedent someone cites next year.

Then say clearly what you're agreeing to: dinner and recognition of getting back together, with the annual date still undecided. If he won't accept that distinction, that's a different conversation from assuming the reservation silently settles everything.

Join the discussion

More in AITA