Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing a DNA test kit my aunt bought for our family-history project?

AITA category photographAITA

"I thought this was what you wanted," my aunt said when I wouldn't open the kit.

We had been researching family history together. I enjoy old records, letters and figuring out who lived where. I had said I'd love to learn more about a branch of the family we knew little about.

She bought a consumer DNA test kit as a surprise and expected us to use the same service. I thanked her but said I wasn't comfortable submitting a sample. She offered to help with the account settings and said she'd already used hers.

I said I wanted to read the provider's current privacy terms before considering anything, and might still decide not to. The FTC's guidance on DNA-test gifts discusses reviewing privacy practices and choices rather than treating the kit as an ordinary present.

My aunt says I made her thoughtful contribution sound reckless. I don't think her own decision was mine to judge. But I also don't think sharing curiosity about family history meant I'd agreed to every method of exploring it.

She has offered to keep the unopened kit. I worry I've discouraged a project I genuinely wanted to share with her. AITA for refusing?

Discussion

5 community replies

The FTC's guidance recommends examining a testing company's privacy practices and available choices, including sharing and deletion. Those details need checking with the actual provider. A relative's positive experience doesn't settle whether you want to submit your own sample.

Your aunt connected enthusiasm for the family-history project with enthusiasm for this method. That was an understandable guess, but it was still a guess. You can appreciate the research partnership while declining the kit.

Be careful not to describe her own decision as foolish when explaining yours. You don't need to persuade her she should regret testing in order to make your no legitimate.

Could you suggest the next record or letter you'd like to investigate together? A concrete continuation would show that the project remains welcome even though this present isn't the method you want.

That would be reassuring if it's sincere. It shouldn't become extra work you owe as compensation for declining. The shared interest can continue at a pace and through methods both people choose, rather than requiring the kit to prove commitment.

Join the discussion

More in AITA