Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for putting on headphones during a train trip with my friend?

AITA category photographAITA

An hour into the journey I put on my headphones and opened a book. My friend asked whether she'd have to book a conversation slot.

We were travelling together for a weekend away. We'd chatted since meeting at the station, and I wanted a quiet stretch before we arrived. I said that, but I'd already put the headphones on without mentioning the plan.

She says she chose the longer train journey partly because it would give us time together. I hadn't known that. I thought travelling together could include both talking and sitting comfortably doing different things.

I offered to put the book away later in the journey. She said she didn't want conversation that had to wait until I'd finished enjoying myself.

I don't want the weekend to become a timetable for talking. I also understand that putting on headphones abruptly may have felt like closing a door while she was still in the conversation. AITA for wanting quiet time on a trip we'd chosen to share?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA for wanting a quiet stretch. You'd already spent time talking, and a shared journey doesn't need one continuous conversation. The abrupt switch is something you can acknowledge without surrendering the quiet time.

She had an expectation you didn't know about. That isn't proof she was unreasonable to want the journey as part of the visit, but it does mean you couldn't have planned around it before she told you.

“I'd like to read for a while” would probably have felt less like being shut out than discovering the headphones already on. Use the sentence before the action next time.

Don't frame every later conversation as the thing you'll do after the real enjoyment. Let her know you're looking forward to the weekend together as well as enjoying the book.

That reassurance can be sincere without accepting her description of the book as competition. You can enjoy an hour alone beside a friend and still want the hours you'll spend together.

Join the discussion

More in AITA