Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for publicly correcting my friend's pronouns after they asked me to keep it brief?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend asked me before dinner to keep any pronoun corrections brief. They use they/them, everyone at the table already knew, and they didn't want the evening to become a discussion about them.

When another friend said “she,” I corrected him to “they.” He said sorry and used the right pronoun when he restarted the sentence. I then added that it wasn't difficult and that we should all be making more effort. He said he was trying. I kept explaining why intentions weren't enough, until my friend changed the subject.

Afterwards they told me I'd done exactly what they'd asked me to avoid. I said I didn't want them to have to defend themselves. They replied that they'd already told me what help they wanted and that I hadn't listened.

I apologised for making the dinner awkward, but also said I thought it mattered to challenge the mistake. They said the brief correction had done that; the speech was for me.

I meant to back them up. I can also see that I kept going after the correction had been accepted. AITA for making the point publicly when the friend most affected had asked for less?

Discussion

5 community replies

YTA for continuing after the correction was accepted. Your friend had given you a specific way to help, and you used it successfully. Then you changed the evening into the discussion they had asked to avoid.

The first correction wasn't the problem. Don't take this as a reason to stay silent next time. Take it as a reason to trust what your friend tells you about how they want mistakes handled around them.

Your apology was for awkwardness, but their complaint was that you didn't listen. A better repair would name that: they asked for a brief correction, you went further, and they ended up having to steer the conversation away.

You can have a separate conversation with the other friend about making an effort if there is something that still needs addressing. That doesn't require your nonbinary friend to sit through the discussion at dinner or reassure either of you afterwards.

I'd be careful even with that separate conversation. In this account he apologised and corrected himself; there's no unresolved refusal to address. Before launching another explanation, consider whether you're responding to something he actually did or trying to finish the speech your friend asked you to stop.

Join the discussion

More in AITA